ProjectionLab alternative
The ProjectionLab alternative with real tax brackets and bank sync.
ProjectionLab has gorgeous visualizations and flexible modeling — but it estimates taxes with presets, doesn't link bank accounts, and Premium is annual-only. cinder.fi gives you real federal + provincial/state bracket math, Plaid bank sync, and $12/mo monthly billing across Canada and the US.
Last verified: 2026-06-13. ProjectionLab's features and pricing change — links go to their own pages.
The short version
ProjectionLab
Best-in-class visualizations and the most flexible scenario modeling, with Monte Carlo and historical backtesting even on the free tier. Genuinely multi-country, including Canada. Premium is $129/yr (annual-only); data entry is manual or via YNAB/Monarch plugins — no direct bank linking.
cinder.fi
Real federal + provincial/state tax brackets (not estimates), direct Plaid bank sync, budgeting that feeds your projection, monthly billing at $12/mo, and an MCP server for AI agents — purpose-built for Canada and the US.
Honest trade-offs
Where each tool wins
Pick ProjectionLab if…
- → You want the best charts and the most flexible scenario branching — that's ProjectionLab's core strength.
- → You want Monte Carlo and historical backtesting on the free tier.
- → You plan in a country beyond Canada and the US — ProjectionLab has presets for a dozen-plus countries.
- → You're happy entering data manually or via YNAB/Monarch and don't need bank aggregation.
Pick cinder.fi if…
- ✓ You want real federal + provincial/state tax brackets, not preset-based estimates.
- ✓ You want direct bank sync — ProjectionLab doesn't link financial accounts at all; cinder.fi uses Plaid.
- ✓ You want monthly billing — ProjectionLab Premium is annual-only ($129/yr); cinder.fi is $12/mo.
- ✓ You're in Canada and want broad coverage — cinder.fi models all 13 provinces vs ProjectionLab's 4 presets.
- ✓ You want your real spending to drive the projection, and to run plans inside Claude/ChatGPT via MCP.
Pricing
What you actually pay
ProjectionLab
Free tier
Forecasting, Monte Carlo, backtesting (Basic)
Paid
$129/yr Premium (annual-only)
Trial
Free tier + paid trial
cinder.fi
Free tier
Full planner — real projections, budgeting, Plaid (1 account), no account required
Paid
$12/mo
Trial
Free tier is the trial
Prices verified 2026-06-13.
Feature comparison
cinder.fi vs ProjectionLab, feature by feature
Tax engine & accuracy
Tax calculation method
Real statutory brackets vs preset estimates
cinder.fi
real fed + prov/state brackets
ProjectionLab
preset-based estimates
Canada support (RRSP/TFSA, CPP/OAS)
Both tools support Canada — difference is depth
cinder.fi
yes (13 provinces)
ProjectionLab
yes (4 provinces)
US support (federal + state)
All 50 states
cinder.fi
yes (50 states + DC)
ProjectionLab
✓
Roth conversion modeling
Convert in low-bracket years
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
✓
Multi-objective optimizer
Auto-sweep timing, withdrawal order, conversions
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
Limited
Data & budgeting
Direct bank sync (Plaid)
Link accounts, auto-pull balances
cinder.fi
yes (1 free)
ProjectionLab
—
How data gets in
Aggregation vs manual entry
cinder.fi
Plaid + CSV/OFX/YNAB
ProjectionLab
YNAB/Monarch plugins, manual
Budget feeds the projection
Real spending → retirement impact
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
—
Transaction import
Bring real history in
cinder.fi
yes (6 formats)
ProjectionLab
Limited
Planning & stress testing
Monte Carlo simulation
Randomized market paths
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
yes (free)
Historical backtest
Test against real market history
cinder.fi
yes (1871–present)
ProjectionLab
✓
Withdrawal strategies
Tax-aware sequencing
cinder.fi
4 built-in + custom
ProjectionLab
✓
Visualizations & scenario UX
Charts + scenario branching
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
best-in-class
Pricing & platform
Monthly billing
Pay monthly, not a year up front
cinder.fi
yes ($12/mo)
ProjectionLab
no (annual)
MCP API for AI agents
19 tools for Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
—
Multi-country (beyond CA/US)
International tax presets
cinder.fi
—
ProjectionLab
yes (12+ countries)
Works without an account
Use immediately, no sign-up
cinder.fi
✓
ProjectionLab
Limited
| Feature | cinder.fi | ProjectionLab |
|---|---|---|
| Tax engine & accuracy | ||
| Tax calculation method Real statutory brackets vs preset estimates | real fed + prov/state brackets | preset-based estimates |
| Canada support (RRSP/TFSA, CPP/OAS) Both tools support Canada — difference is depth | yes (13 provinces) | yes (4 provinces) |
| US support (federal + state) All 50 states | yes (50 states + DC) | ✓ |
| Roth conversion modeling Convert in low-bracket years | ✓ | ✓ |
| Multi-objective optimizer Auto-sweep timing, withdrawal order, conversions | ✓ | Limited |
| Data & budgeting | ||
| Direct bank sync (Plaid) Link accounts, auto-pull balances | yes (1 free) | — |
| How data gets in Aggregation vs manual entry | Plaid + CSV/OFX/YNAB | YNAB/Monarch plugins, manual |
| Budget feeds the projection Real spending → retirement impact | ✓ | — |
| Transaction import Bring real history in | yes (6 formats) | Limited |
| Planning & stress testing | ||
| Monte Carlo simulation Randomized market paths | ✓ | yes (free) |
| Historical backtest Test against real market history | yes (1871–present) | ✓ |
| Withdrawal strategies Tax-aware sequencing | 4 built-in + custom | ✓ |
| Visualizations & scenario UX Charts + scenario branching | ✓ | best-in-class |
| Pricing & platform | ||
| Monthly billing Pay monthly, not a year up front | yes ($12/mo) | no (annual) |
| MCP API for AI agents 19 tools for Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor | ✓ | — |
| Multi-country (beyond CA/US) International tax presets | — | yes (12+ countries) |
| Works without an account Use immediately, no sign-up | ✓ | Limited |
Frequently asked questions
› Is cinder.fi a good ProjectionLab alternative?
Yes, if you want real federal + provincial/state tax brackets instead of preset estimates, direct bank sync, or monthly billing. ProjectionLab is the better pick if you want best-in-class visualizations, the most flexible scenario branching, Monte Carlo and backtesting on the free tier, or planning in a country beyond Canada and the US.
› Does ProjectionLab support Canada?
Yes — ProjectionLab supports Canada with TFSA, RRSP, and RRIF accounts, CPP/OAS/GIS modeling, and provincial presets for Ontario, Alberta, BC, and Quebec. The difference is depth: cinder.fi models all 13 provinces and territories using real federal + provincial tax brackets, while ProjectionLab frames its Canadian tax features as presets and effective-rate estimates covering four provinces.
› Can I link my bank to ProjectionLab?
Not directly. ProjectionLab does not support linking financial accounts; you update balances manually or through its plugin system (YNAB and Monarch Money). cinder.fi links accounts directly via Plaid (one account free, unlimited on Pro) and also imports CSV/OFX/YNAB files.
› How much does ProjectionLab cost vs cinder.fi?
ProjectionLab Premium is $129/year, billed annually — there is no individual monthly plan (monthly billing exists only on the advisor Pro tier). cinder.fi is free to start, with Pro at $12/month. Pricing verified 2026-06-13.
› Does ProjectionLab have Monte Carlo simulation?
Yes — Monte Carlo and historical backtesting are available even on ProjectionLab's free tier, which is a genuine strength. cinder.fi also includes both (with backtesting to 1871) plus a multi-objective optimizer, real bank sync, and budgeting that feeds the projection.
Built by the cinder.fi team. Where ProjectionLab does something we don't, this page says so plainly. Spot something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Start with a situation like yours.
See how spending, life events, and retirement timing fit together.
Start with your situation